Innovations by Vanessa Cordeiro and Chris Glynn of Somerville High School
Post written by Dr. Alice Mello and Dr. Susan Klimczak of OneVille
A couple months into the exploratory phase of our Somerville High School ePortfolio Project, we saw the effects of the participatory design based approach with students and teachers have an innovative impact in a classroom.
Vanessa Cordeiro, one of our senior year student participants, asked her Social Studies teacher, Mr. Glynn, who is also one of the teacher participants in the ePortfolio project at SHS, if she could do a class assignment as an entry for her ePortfolio. In this class assignment, Mr. Glynn’s students write a “paper and pencil” media literacy journal over the course of several weeks and record how news stories are presented in different types of media. These journals are usually turned in and commented on by Mr. Glynn only at the end of the assignment.
After saying yes to Vanessa, Mr. Glynn had an idea: to have all his students create digital journals. He linked those journals on his web page. Now, he and his students are able to get ideas from each other and engage in daily on-line conversations about their journals during the assignment, instead of having only Mr. Glynn read and give comments at the end.
Mr. Glynn reports that students were enthusiastic about the digital process. They created their digital journals using google sites and wiki spaces, exactly the same platform used by the ePortfolio’s participants.
Mr. Glynn admits that he is not the most digitally active teacher at Somerville High School, but he was pleased with the results. Here is what he told us about his experience:
“This is great, this is so much easier [for me] than paper. And it’s alive, it’s sort of a living thing that they can keep changing and adding to. . . “
“it is something that is already on display as it is being created. . It is not only a conversation between a student and me. I have the kids. . .linked all on my page so they can look at each other’s journal entries. It makes it a bit more open forum and. . .more discussion can come from that and that is a good thing.”
There is much that can be observed as significant in this story. What Mr. Glynn told us mirrors a OneVille belief: that making communication about learning more possible among students and between students and teachers can increase student success.
Vanessa found the process of making an ePortfolio important enough for her learning to request that a teacher allow her to use it in everyday assignments. The actions of Mr. Glynn and Vanessa indicate their belief in the legitimacy of ePortfolios in education, as well as a belief in their own power and agency to initiate using ePortfolios skillfully to increase learning.
The story also highlights the possibility that ePortfolio practice can be “incorporated from below” in a school — gradually be developed as part of everyday classroom practice by teachers and students — rather than “scaled up whole from above.” Introducing ePortfolios gradually into classroom practice over time could possibly have an innovative and positive influence on school learning culture.
Finally and perhaps most significantly, this story highlights the importance of considering students and teachers seriously as sources of education innovation. In fact, the ePortfolio participatory research design was based on our belief that students’ and teachers’ contributions to OneVille’s research and education reform efforts in Somerville are so significant that they should be paid for their participation.
